Otterbein St Marys Retirement Community

Assisted LivingNursing Home

11230 State Route 364
St Marys, OH 45885 · Auglaize County
View on map

Call (419) 394-6330

Official website not yet verified

Overall Medicare rating★★★★★
Overall: state avg 3.2 · U.S. 3.0
Health inspections★★★★★
Staffing★★★★★
Staffing: state avg 2.4 · U.S. 3.0
Quality measures★★★★★

Source: CMS Care Compare (data as of October 1, 2026)

View Safety Report

Safety at a glance

1Serious citations (actual harm or immediate jeopardy), last 3 inspection cycles
20Total health citations, last 3 inspection cycles
$0Federal fines, last 3 years (0 fines)

Most recent standard inspection: June 25, 2026.

Most recent serious findings

G
Ensure that a nursing home area is free from accident hazards and provides adequate supervision to prevent accidents.
November 14, 2023 · Inspectors rated this “actual harm to a resident (not immediate jeopardy).” The problem affected one or a very small number of residents or staff. Found during a complaint investigation.

View the full Safety Report →

Availability

Availability Unknown

This facility has not confirmed current availability. We never estimate vacancies. Please call (419) 394-6330 to ask about openings and waiting lists.

We'll show the answer here once the facility provides it.

E-mail Otterbein St Marys Retirement Community about openings We help you write the message; you send it from your own e-mail.

Nurse staffing

Total nurse hours per resident per day
3.64 hours · state avg 3.71, U.S. 3.90
Registered nurse (RN) hours per resident per day
0.84 hours
Total nurse hours on weekends
3.25 hours · state avg 3.29
Nursing staff turnover (yearly)
30.6% · state avg 49.0%
RN turnover (yearly)
25%
Administrators who left (yearly)
0

Hours per resident per day = total nursing hours worked ÷ number of residents. Higher usually means more hands-on time. Values are from payroll records reported to CMS (Payroll-Based Journal).

Source: CMS Provider Information (data as of October 1, 2026)

Paying for care

Medicaid: This nursing home is certified to accept Medicaid. It is also Medicare certified, so Medicare can pay for short-term skilled care after a qualifying hospital stay.

In Ohio, Medicaid long-term care is provided through PASSPORT Waiver.

Ways to pay for care in Ohio →

Pricing

Published price: Not Yet Verified

What families report paying

No family reports yet. To protect privacy and avoid misleading figures, we show a summary only after 5 reports.

Yearly price increases

No increase reports yet. Shown after 5 reports.

We'll show the answer here once the facility provides it.

Nursing home care may be paid by Medicare (short-term skilled care after a qualifying hospital stay), Medicaid (if eligible), long-term care insurance, or privately. This facility is Medicaid certified.

Family Cameras & Video Access

Family-installed room cameras
Not Verified
Facility-provided room cameras
Not Verified
Authorized remote family viewing
Not Verified
Live video visitation
Not Verified
We'll show the answer here once the facility provides it.

We have not yet verified this facility’s camera policy. Rules for in-room cameras vary by state and usually require consent from the resident and any roommate. Ask the facility for its written electronic-monitoring policy.

Applying & contacting

Online admission application
Not yet checked
Online waiting-list form
Not yet checked
Online inquiry form
Not yet checked
Online tour scheduling
Not yet checked
We'll show the answer here once the facility provides it.

Application checklist & links Applying to several facilities? Add each one to your compare list and open the apply page.

Ownership

Ownership type
Non profit - Corporation
Chain / affiliation
Otterbein Seniorlife
Legal business name
Otterbein St Marys
Owner or managerRoleShare
OTTERBEIN HOME5% OR GREATER INDIRECT OWNERSHIP INTEREST100%
OTTERBEIN LSC LLC5% OR GREATER DIRECT OWNERSHIP INTEREST100%
APP, LYNNOPERATIONAL/MANAGERIAL CONTROL—
BAKER, STEVEINDIVIDUAL IS AN OWNER, PARTNER OR TRUSTEE OF ANY ADP OF THE SNF—
BARTLETT, VICTORIAOPERATIONAL/MANAGERIAL CONTROL—
BAYLIFF, BECKYOPERATIONAL/MANAGERIAL CONTROL—
BORNS, DEBORAHMANAGING CONTROL - GOVERNING BODY—
BORNS, DEBORAHTRUSTEE OF THE SNF—
BROWNSON, WILLIAMOPERATIONAL/MANAGERIAL CONTROL—
BURKE, DANIELOPERATIONAL/MANAGERIAL CONTROL—
COFFIN, GORDONMANAGING CONTROL - GOVERNING BODY—
COFFIN, GORDONTRUSTEE OF THE SNF—

Source: CMS Provider Information (data as of October 1, 2026)

About this listing

CMS Certification Number
365953
Certified beds
53
Average residents per day
47.8
Medicare / Medicaid
Medicare and Medicaid
Continuing care retirement community
Yes
First certified
February 9, 1994
Last confirmed by official source
October 1, 2026

Read full inspection narratives at Medicare Care Compare or ProPublica Nursing Home Inspect.

Nearby facilities

Grande Lake Healthcare Center

1209 Indiana Avenue, St Marys, OH 45885 · 2.8 miles away
Assisted Living · Nursing Home45 certified bedsAccepts MedicaidMedicare certified(419) 394-7611
Availability Unknown
Overall (Medicare)★★★★★
Health inspections★★★★★
Staffing★★★★★
Serious citations*1
View details

Vancrest of St Mary'S

1035 Hager Street, St Marys, OH 45885 · 3.5 miles away
Assisted Living · Nursing Home66 certified bedsAccepts MedicaidMedicare certified(419) 394-3308
Availability Unknown
Overall (Medicare)★★★★★
Health inspections★★★★★
Staffing★★★★★
Serious citations*0
View details

Transitional Care Unit

200 St Clair Street, Saint Marys, OH 45885 · 3.6 miles away
Nursing Home15 certified bedsMedicare certified(419) 394-3335
Availability Unknown
Overall (Medicare)★★★★★
Health inspections★★★★★
Staffing★★★★★
Serious citations*0
View details

Gardens At Celina

1301 Myers Road, Celina, OH 45822 · 7.4 miles away
Assisted Living · Nursing Home25 certified bedsAccepts MedicaidMedicare certified(419) 584-0100
Availability Unknown
Overall (Medicare)★★★★★
Health inspections★★★★★
Staffing★★★★★
Serious citations*0
View details
Compare